How to Make Sugar Cream Pie: A Classic Recipe

I still remember the first time I tasted sugar cream pie. It was at my grandmother’s farmhouse in Indiana, the sweet aroma filling her sunny kitchen as she pulled the golden-brown pie from the oven. The silky, custard-like filling with its warm hints of vanilla and nutmeg became an instant comfort food for me. Did you know that sugar cream pie has been a beloved Midwestern staple since the 1800s, with Indiana officially declaring it the state pie in 2009? This deceptively simple Sugar Cream Pie combines basic pantry ingredients into something truly extraordinary.

Why Sugar Cream Pie Matters

Sugar Cream Pie represents the beautiful simplicity of American farmhouse baking—a dessert born of necessity when fresh fruits weren’t available. Often called “desperation pie” or “Hoosier pie,” this humble dessert has stood the test of time because of its incredible flavor and texture achieved with minimal ingredients.

For those looking to explore different variations, the Hoosier Sugar Cream Pie Recipe from Serious Eats offers a slightly different approach to this classic, while Allrecipes’ Sugar Cream Pie version has been tested by thousands of home bakers. If you enjoy creamy desserts, you might also appreciate these Lazy Day Lemon Cream Pie Bars or No-Bake Peanut Butter Oat Cups for equally satisfying treats.

Ingredients for the Perfect Sugar Cream Pie

Sugar Cream Pie Ingredients

For the crust:

• 1 1/2 cups all-purpose flour
• 1/2 teaspoon salt
• 1/2 cup cold unsalted butter, cubed
• 4-5 tablespoons ice water

For the filling:

• 1 cup granulated sugar
• 1/4 cup cornstarch
• 2 cups half-and-half
• 1/2 cup heavy cream
• 4 tablespoons unsalted butter, cubed
• 1 teaspoon pure vanilla extract
• 1/4 teaspoon ground nutmeg (plus more for topping)
• Pinch of salt

Don’t have half-and-half? Substitute with equal parts whole milk and heavy cream. For a dairy-free version, coconut cream can replace heavy cream, though it will add a subtle coconut flavor that complements the vanilla beautifully.

Ingredient Spotlight: Why Each Element Matters in Sugar Cream Pie

The magic of Sugar Cream Pie lies in its carefully balanced ingredients:

Half-and-half and heavy cream: These create the luxurious mouthfeel that defines a true Sugar Cream Pie. The fat content is crucial for that silky texture that melts on your tongue.

Cornstarch: This thickening agent gives the filling its perfect consistency—firm enough to slice cleanly but soft enough to feel indulgent. Without it, you’d have sweet cream soup!

Butter: Beyond flavor, butter adds richness and helps create that distinctive caramelized top when broiled briefly at the end of baking.

Nutmeg: This warming spice cuts through the sweetness and adds depth. Freshly grated makes a noticeable difference, but pre-ground works well too.

Vanilla: The aromatic foundation that elevates Sugar Cream Pie from simple to sublime. Use pure extract rather than imitation for the best flavor.

Timing: From Pantry to Plate

• Prep time: 30 minutes (including crust preparation)
• Chill time: 1 hour (for the crust)
• Bake time: 45-50 minutes
• Cooling time: Minimum 2 hours
• Total time: Approximately 4 hours, 20 minutes

While this might seem lengthy, the actual hands-on time is only about 45 minutes—40% less active work than many other custard-based pies. Most of the time is passive cooling and setting, during which you’re free to tackle other kitchen adventures.

Step-by-Step Instructions for Sugar Cream Pie

Step 1: Prepare the Pie Crust

Mix flour and salt in a large bowl. Cut in cold butter with a pastry blender until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs. Gradually add ice water, one tablespoon at a time, until the dough holds together when pinched. Form into a disk, wrap in plastic, and refrigerate for at least one hour.

Erin’s Tip: Freeze your butter for 15 minutes before cutting it into the flour—colder butter creates flakier crusts as it releases steam during baking.

Step 2: Roll and Blind Bake the Crust

Preheat your oven to 375°F. Roll the chilled dough on a floured surface to 1/8-inch thickness. Transfer to a 9-inch pie plate, trim and crimp edges. Line with parchment paper, fill with pie weights or dried beans, and bake for 15 minutes. Remove weights and parchment, then bake for another 5-7 minutes until light golden. Cool completely.

Erin’s Tip: Dock the crust (prick with a fork) before adding weights to prevent air bubbles and ensure even baking.

Step 3: Prepare the Filling

In a medium saucepan, whisk together sugar and cornstarch. Gradually whisk in half-and-half and heavy cream until smooth. Cook over medium heat, stirring constantly, until the mixture comes to a boil and thickens, about 5-7 minutes.

Erin’s Tip: A silicone whisk won’t scratch your cookware and helps reach the corners of the saucepan where scorching often begins.

Step 4: Finish the Filling

Remove from heat and stir in butter, vanilla, nutmeg, and salt until butter is completely melted. The mixture should coat the back of a spoon.

Erin’s Tip: Pour the filling through a fine-mesh sieve to ensure silky smoothness and catch any bits that might have coagulated during cooking.

Step 5: Bake the Pie

Pour the filling into the cooled pie crust. Sprinkle additional nutmeg over the top. Bake at 350°F for 25 minutes until the edges are set but the center still has a slight jiggle.

Erin’s Tip: Place the pie on a baking sheet to catch any potential overflow and make transferring in and out of the oven easier.

Step 6: Brown the Top (Optional but Traditional)

For that authentic Sugar Cream Pie finish, switch the oven to broil. Place the pie on the middle rack and broil for 1-2 minutes until the top develops brown speckles. Watch carefully—it can burn quickly!

Erin’s Tip: Rotate the pie halfway through broiling for even browning.

Step 7: Cool and Set

Allow the pie to cool completely at room temperature, then refrigerate for at least 2 hours or overnight to fully set.

Erin’s Tip: Place a paper towel over the pie (not touching the filling) before covering with plastic wrap to prevent condensation from dripping onto your beautiful creation.

Tips & Tricks for Perfect Sugar Cream Pie

1. Temperature matters: Ensure all refrigerated ingredients come to room temperature before mixing for the smoothest texture.
2. Patience pays off: Don’t rush the stovetop thickening process—hurrying can lead to lumps or scorching.
3. The jiggle test: When checking doneness, the pie should wiggle slightly in the center when gently shaken. It will set further as it cools.
4. Shield the edges: If your crust starts browning too quickly during baking, cover the edges with foil.
5. Complete cooling: Resist the temptation to cut into the pie before it’s fully cooled and set—at least 2 hours in the refrigerator yields the best texture and flavor.

Sugar Cream Pie Variations & Substitutions

Maple Sugar Cream Pie: Replace half the granulated sugar with pure maple syrup and reduce the half-and-half by 2 tablespoons to maintain the proper consistency.

Brown Sugar Cream Pie: Substitute light or dark brown sugar for granulated sugar to create a more caramel-like flavor profile with delicious molasses undertones.

Spiced Sugar Cream Pie: Add 1/2 teaspoon of cinnamon and a pinch of cloves along with the nutmeg for a warming spice blend reminiscent of chai.

Gluten-Free Option: Use your favorite gluten-free pie crust recipe or pre-made gluten-free crust. The filling is naturally gluten-free, just double-check your cornstarch brand.

Behind the Recipe: The Story of Sugar Cream Pie

Sugar Cream Pie traces its American roots to the early 1800s in Indiana, where it became popular among Shaker and Amish communities. Its simple ingredients—sugar, cream, and flour—made it accessible even during harsh winters or hard times when eggs and fresh fruit were scarce.

What fascinates me about this pie is how it traveled through generations as a cherished heirloom recipe, rarely changing much because its perfection lies in its simplicity. Many families have their own slight variations, passed down through handwritten recipe cards and oral traditions. My version comes from my grandmother’s collection, with just a few modern adjustments for foolproof results.

Pairing Ideas

Sugar Cream Pie pairs beautifully with:

• Freshly brewed coffee, especially dark roasts that balance the sweetness
• Hot apple cider with cinnamon sticks
• A glass of cold milk
• Homemade whipped cream with a hint of vanilla
• Fresh berries on the side for a bright contrast

Leftover & Reuse Ideas

Sugar Cream Pie rarely lasts long enough for leftovers, but if you find yourself with extra:

• Crumble leftovers into vanilla ice cream for a pie-inspired sundae
• Blend a slice with milk and vanilla ice cream for a Sugar Cream Pie milkshake
• Layer pieces with whipped cream and berries in a parfait glass for a quick trifle

Nutritional Information

One slice of Sugar Cream Pie (1/8 of pie) contains approximately:

• Calories: 380
• Fat: 24g
• Carbohydrates: 39g
• Protein: 3g
• Sugar: 28g

Serving Suggestions

Present your Sugar Cream Pie in style with these ideas:

• Dust the top with an additional sprinkle of nutmeg just before serving
• Add a dollop of whipped cream and a fresh mint leaf for color contrast
• Serve on vintage plates with teacups of coffee for a charming presentation
• For gatherings, pre-slice the pie and place each slice on individual dessert plates with fresh berries for easy serving

Common Mistakes to Avoid When Making Sugar Cream Pie

1. 
   

   Undercooking the filling: The stovetop mixture must come to a full boil to activate the cornstarch’s thickening properties. You’ll know it’s ready when it coats the back of a spoon and leaves a clean line when you run your finger through it.

   
   
2. 
   

   Scorching the filling: Use medium heat and stir constantly, especially as the mixture begins to thicken. A heavy-bottomed saucepan helps distribute heat more evenly.

   
   
3. 
   

   Cutting the pie too soon: The filling needs time to fully set. Cutting too early results in a runny center that won’t hold its shape.

   
   
4. 
   

   Overbaking: Watch closely during the final minutes. The filling should retain some jiggle in the center when you remove it from the oven.

   
   
5. 
   

   Broiling too long: Those characteristic brown speckles can quickly turn to burnt spots if left under the broiler too long. Stay vigilant during this step!

   
   

Storage & Reheating Tips

Sugar Cream Pie should be refrigerated and will keep well for 3-4 days. Cover loosely with plastic wrap after the pie has completely cooled.

This pie doesn’t require reheating, and in fact, is traditionally enjoyed cold straight from the refrigerator. However, if you prefer it less chilled, let it sit at room temperature for 15-20 minutes before serving.

For make-ahead preparation, you can blind-bake the crust up to 2 days in advance. Store in an airtight container at room temperature until needed.

Frequently Asked Questions About Sugar Cream Pie

What makes a Sugar Cream Pie authentic?

An authentic Sugar Cream Pie features a creamy, pudding-like filling made primarily from sugar, cream, and a thickener, traditionally flour or cornstarch. The Hoosier (Indiana) version typically has nutmeg sprinkled on top and those characteristic browned speckles from a quick broil.

Can Sugar Cream Pie be made without baking?

Traditional Sugar Cream Pie recipes require baking to set the filling properly and create that signature texture. While no-bake cream pies exist, they won’t deliver the same authentic experience as a true Sugar Cream Pie.

Why did my Sugar Cream Pie not set properly?

If your pie didn’t set, the filling likely didn’t reach a high enough temperature on the stovetop to fully activate the cornstarch. Make sure it comes to a gentle boil and thickens noticeably before pouring it into the crust.

Is Sugar Cream Pie served warm or cold?

Sugar Cream Pie is traditionally served cold or at room temperature after it has fully set. This allows the flavors to meld and the texture to reach its ideal consistency.

How long does Sugar Cream Pie last?

When properly stored in the refrigerator, Sugar Cream Pie will remain fresh for 3-4 days. The texture is best within the first 48 hours after baking.

The Sweet Finale

Sugar Cream Pie embodies the beauty of heritage baking—simple ingredients transformed into something memorable through technique and tradition. This custard-like dessert proves that sometimes the most straightforward recipes become the most beloved. Whether you’re connecting with your Midwestern roots or discovering this classic for the first time, Sugar Cream Pie offers a taste of American history in every silky, sweet bite.

Made this Sugar Cream Pie? Drop your twist in the comments, rate the recipe, and tag us on facebook, instagram with #erinrecipes — we might feature your creation!

Print